Where simple trackers break
A tracker that follows straight, well-separated targets can still fail at the two things real targets do: turn hard, and pass close to each other. Each section runs several methods on exactly the same detections, replays one recorded run side by side, and then gives the measured rates over many runs.
A sharp turn
One target flies straight, turns hard, then flies straight again. A tracker predicts where the target will be next and looks for it there, and how wide it looks is a setting: too narrow and a hard turn costs the track, too wide and every straight leg costs accuracy. One recorded run first, the same detections for every method:
–
What each method does
Measured over many runs
| method | kept one track through the turn | straight-leg error | turn error | turn, worst 5% | pieces per target |
|---|
–
–
–
Two targets crossing
Two targets fly towards each other at a shallow angle and pass within a few metres. Near the crossing both tracks see both detections, and the tracker has to decide, scan by scan, which detection belongs to which track. Get it wrong once and the identities swap: the track that followed one target now follows the other, with nothing on the screen to say so. One recorded run first:
–
What each method does
- Greedy gives each track the closest free detection, closest pair first.
- GNN (global nearest neighbour) solves the whole assignment at once: the best total fit for this scan.
- JPDA does not commit near a crossing: it updates each track with a blend of the nearby detections, weighted by how likely each one is to be its own.
One would expect the best total fit to be the safest choice at a crossing. It is not automatically so: the best fit for one scan is not the same thing as the best identity history. The measured rates below decide, not the expectation. They start at the shallowest crossing, where the methods differ most; wider angles are one click away.
Measured over many runs
| method | identities swapped | both identities kept | identity switches per run |
|---|
–
–
–
e8.json, e9.json), read by the page as it loads; nothing here is simulated in your browser.